Rototilling Your Spring Garden
The soil should be moist before tilling, not saturated and soggy just moist. Don't try to rototill wet flooded soil it will only increase compaction and the amount of clumps and clods. The soil should also not be overly dry and dehydrated as this will create a dusty soil subject to erosion by wind and rain.
Test your soils moisture by digging out a shovelful, you should be able to make a dirt ball with the soil from the bottom of the hole that easily falls apart. If you can't make a dirt ball the soil is probably too dry, if it doesn't fall apart all that easily or you are able to squeeze water out of it obviously it is too wet. Water overly dry soil and leave it for a few days before testing it again.
Remove any grass clumps, or invasive perennial weeds such as dandelions, rototilling may seem to kill them but in the long run you are actually spreading weeds and grass throughout your garden area. Many weeds will regenerate from a root fragment.
Remove any vines, especially the ground huggers as they have a tendency to become wrapped around the tines and bog down the machine. Ditto for remnants of plastic mulch from past seasons.
Extremely compacted soil is generally difficult to break through, especially the top layer. I prefer to make several passes if it is very hard soil. The first pass only to break through the harder outer crust and subsequent passes to till the soil to the correct depth and consistency. Assuming your machine has various settings to adjust the tines depth, aka a depth bar, as well as adjustable rotation speeds you should be readjusting these after the initial pass. The slower you till, the better and finer you'll grinding the dirt.
A depth of 5 - 6 inches is okay for leafy annual vegetables and flowers. Root vegetables need several inches more, around 8 inches. Very few tillers go much deeper than that. You actually will want to avoid excessive deep tilling in order to curtail damage to beneficial organisms such as earth worms. Excessively pulverizing the soil decreases their ability to survive and hampers the garden soils future viability.
The first pass should be around 4 inches 6 inches at most. The second and subsequent passes should be set for a deeper setting, around 8 inches or more if your rototiller has that capacity. You'll also want to increase the speed as the soil becomes more broken up.
Alternate the direction in which you till the ground. If you till in an east west direction on the first pass change to a north south orientation for the second and so forth.
Avoid tilling too close to trees you could damage the roots as well as the machine.
Test Garden Soil Yourself
Leaf Mold Composting Understanding Fertilizer Labels